Pies

Our whole pies

This is our current menu of pies available right now. Our menu changes monthly and seasonally. We accept orders for whole pies with a minimum of 48 hours notice, but some days may sell out before others— especially holiday weekends. You can place your pre-paid order online or call the shop during business hours. We also stock our case each day with extra whole pies after we have fulfilled pre-orders, so if you missed the cutoff for ordering, feel free to call the shop to see if we have an extra whole pie available or view our same-day menu online. Flavors are bakers’ choice.

Order for a Future Date Order for Today

6" Cutie Pies

Limited Release

Sweet Pies

Custom Pies

Whoopie Pies by the Dozen

Quiche

Spirit Sprinkles by Pie Junkie

Pie Crusts

Frozen Take & Bake Meals

Pie Add-ons

Merch

WAITRESS TICKETHOLDERS ONLY (Lyric Theater Delivery)

We’re not the only ones who love our pies

USA Today BuzzFeed Vogue