Our whole pies
This is our current menu of pies available right now. Our menu changes monthly and seasonally. We accept orders for whole pies with a minimum of 48 hours notice, but some days may sell out before others— especially holiday weekends. You can place your pre-paid order online or call the shop during business hours. We also stock our case each day with extra whole pies after we have fulfilled pre-orders, so if you missed the cutoff for ordering, feel free to call the shop to see if we have an extra whole pie available or view our same-day menu online. Flavors are bakers’ choice.
6" Cutie Pies
View Details
6" Cutie Pie - Apple Crumble
$12.00
Our popular Apple Crumble in a 6" sharable cutie pie size. Flaky crust filled with granny smith apples. Lightly sweetened …
View Details
6" Cutie Pie - Birthday Pie
$12.00
Our famous Birthday Pie in a 6" sharable cutie pie size! Vanilla wafer + sprinkle crust filled with confetti cake …
View Details
6" Cutie Pie - Cherry Crumble
$15.00
Our Cherry Crumble Pie in a 6" sharable cutie pie size. Butter crust filled with a mixture of tart & …
View Details
6" Cutie Pie - Drunken Turtle
$12.00
Our best-selling Drunken Turtle Pie in a 6" sharable cutie pie size. Graham cracker crust with a fudgy chocolate filling, …
View Details
6" Cutie Pie - Key Lime w/ Whip
$10.00
Our popular Key Lime Pie in a 6" sharable cutie pie size! Hand-pressed Graham Cracker crust filled with tart & …
View Details
6" Cutie Pie - Peach Blackberry Crumble
$12.00
Our Peach Blackberry Crumble Pie in a 6" sharable cutie pie size. Flaky crust filled with a tart and slightly …
View Details
6" Cutie Pie - Peanut Butter Chocolate
$10.00
Our Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie in a 6" sharable cutie pie size. Graham cracker crust spread with chocolate ganache & …
Ready to Serve Sweet Pies
View Details
Apple Crumble (do not freeze)
$30.00
Flaky crust filled with granny smith apples. Lightly sweetened with cinnamon & sugar and topped with our brown sugar oat …
View Details
Apple Crumble w/ Salted Bourbon Caramel
$40.00
The perfect pair! Flaky crust filled with granny smith apples, lightly sweetened with cinnamon & sugar and topped with our …
View Details
Bird Dog Buttermilk (freezes well)
$26.00
Traditional buttermilk pie with a splash of Bird Dog Blackberry Whiskey. The Bird Dog gives a subtle berry undertone. If …
View Details
Birthday Pie
$34.00
Our most festive pie ever! Vanilla wafer & sprinkle crust filled with confetti cake batter mousse. Topped with a fluffy …
View Details
Blushing Birthday Pie (do not freeze)
$34.00
A fun new spin on a familiar favorite to celebrate our 12th anniversary! Sprinkle cookie crust filled with a whipped …
View Details
Cherry Crumble (do not freeze)
$44.00
Our cherry filling is a mixture of tart & sweet cherries, cooked in a glaze until thick. Topped with our …
View Details
Classic Apple (do not freeze)
$34.00
Flaky crust filled with granny smith apples. Lightly sweetened with cinnamon & sugar and topped with a sugared crust. Note: …
View Details
Classic Cherry (do not freeze)
$44.00
Our cherry filling is a mixture of tart & sweet cherries, cooked in a glaze until thick. Topped with our …
View Details
Classic Peach Pie (do not freeze)
$34.00
Sliced peaches cooked into a sweet glaze and topped with a butter crust & crunchy raw sugar. Add an 8 …
View Details
Classic Strawberry Rhubarb (do not freeze)
$38.00
Tart rhubarb and sweet, fresh strawberries are the perfect warm weather combination. Baked in a flaky crust and topped with …
View Details
Coconut Cream (do not freeze)
$28.00
Flaky crust filled with our signature coconut pastry cream and topped with lightly sweetened fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut. …
View Details
Drunken Turtle (freezes well)
$34.00
Graham cracker crust with a fudgy chocolate filling, topped with our salted bourbon caramel & pecans. Our best seller… rich …
View Details
French Silk (do not freeze)
$34.00
Flaky crust with a layer of chocolate ganache & filled with chocolate pastry cream. Topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream …
View Details
Kentucky Bourbon (freezes well)
$28.00
Our gooey filling (similar to pecan pie) is kicked up with bourbon, walnuts & chocolate chips. If you like pecan …
View Details
Key Lime - Plain (do not freeze)
$32.00
Hand-pressed Graham Cracker crust filled with tart & sweet Key Lime pie filling. Does not freeze well, best when …
View Details
Key Lime w/ Whip Border (do not freeze)
$34.00
Hand-pressed Graham Cracker crust filled with tart & sweet Key Lime pie filling. Piped with a fresh whipped cream border. …
View Details
Lemon Cream (do not freeze)
$28.00
Flaky crust filled with a tart lemon filling and topped with lightly sweetened whipped cream. Best when enjoyed within 24 …
View Details
Peach Blackberry Crumble (do not freeze)
$36.00
Flaky crust filled with lightly sweetened peaches and blackberries, topped with our brown sugar oat crumble. Available for a limited …
View Details
Peach Crumble (do not freeze)
$30.00
Sliced peaches cooked into a sweet glaze and topped with brown sugar oat crumble. Add an 8 oz. container of …
View Details
Peanut Butter Chocolate (freezes well)
$28.00
Graham cracker crust spread with chocolate ganache & filled with a rich peanut butter mousse. Must love peanut butter! Best …
View Details
Pecan (freezes well)
$28.00
A traditional pecan pie in our flaky crust. Delicious! Best when enjoyed within 5 days of preparation. Freezes well. Whole …
View Details
Pineapple Millionaire (do not freeze)
$28.00
Flaky crust with a layer of whipped buttercream frosting & filled with fluffy pineapple & pecan filling. Best when enjoyed …
View Details
Southern Banana Cream (do not freeze)
$34.00
Vanilla wafer cookie crust filled with layers of vanilla pastry cream & fresh sliced bananas. Topped with a fresh pudding …
View Details
Southern Banana Cream w/ Salted Bourbon Caramel
$44.00
Vanilla wafer cookie crust filled with layers of vanilla pastry cream & fresh sliced bananas. Topped with a fresh pudding …
View Details
Strawberry Diner (do not freeze)
$38.00
Fresh strawberries in a light glaze, piled high in a flaky crust and topped with homemade whipped cream. Best when …
View Details
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble (do not freeze)
$34.00
Tart rhubarb and sweet, fresh strawberries in our flaky pie crust, topped with brown sugar oat crumble. Note: our fruit …
Frozen Sweet Pies
View Details
Frozen Take & Bake - Apple Crumble
$30.00
Our Take & Bake Apple Crumble pie is frozen, unbaked, so you can take it home and bake it off …
View Details
Frozen Take & Bake - Cherry Crumble
$44.00
Our Take & Bake Cherry Crumble pie is frozen, unbaked, so you can take it home and bake it off …
View Details
Frozen Take & Bake - Peach Blackberry Crumble
$36.00
Our Take & Bake Peach Blackberry Crumble pie is frozen, unbaked, so you can take it home and bake it …
View Details
Frozen Take & Bake - Peach Crumble
$30.00
Our Take & Bake Peach Crumble pie is frozen, unbaked, so you can take it home and bake it off …
View Details
Frozen Take & Bake - Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble
$34.00
Our Take & Bake Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble pie is frozen, unbaked, so you can take it home and bake it …
View Details
S'More (FROZEN)
$26.00
*This pie is frozen and should be thawed in the refrigerator before heating & serving* Can remain frozen for up …
Custom Pies
View Details
Gender Reveal Pie - Birthday Pie
$38.00
The sweetest way to announce your new baby! Our popular Birthday Pie with a pink or blue layer... you tell …
View Details
Gender Reveal Pie - Key Lime
$38.00
The sweetest way to announce your new baby! Our popular Key Lime Pie with a pink or blue layer... you …
Whoopie Pies by the Dozen
View Details
Birthday Cake Whoopie Pies - 1 dozen
$40.00
One dozen of our famous Birthday Cake Whoopie Pies, boxed and ready to enjoy! Cake batter buttercream frosting sandwiched between …
View Details
Cookies & Cream Whoopie Pies - 1 dozen
$40.00
One dozen of our Cookies & Cream Whoopie Pies, boxed and ready to enjoy! Oreo buttercream frosting sandwiched between two …
View Details
Oatmeal Cream Whoopie Pies - 1 dozen
$40.00
One dozen of our Oatmeal Cream Whoopie Pies, boxed and ready to enjoy! Classic buttercream frosting sandwiched between two thick …
View Details
Red Velvet Whoopie Pies - 1 dozen
$40.00
One dozen of our Red Velvet Whoopie Pies, boxed and ready to enjoy! Cream cheese frosting sandwiched between two red …
Quiche
View Details
Chorizo, Potato & Green Chile Quiche (freezes well)
$34.00
Flaky crust filled with spicy chorizo sausage, roasted potatoes, green chilies and cheddar baked up with our creamy egg filling. …
View Details
Herbed Ham & Cheddar Quiche (freezes well)
$34.00
Flaky crust filled with diced ham, fresh rosemary and gooey cheddar cheese baked up with our creamy egg filling. Freezes …
View Details
Roasted Broccoli & Cheddar Quiche (freezes well)
$34.00
Flaky crust filled with roasted broccoli & cheddar cheese then baked up with our creamy egg filling. You won't miss …
View Details
Sausage Quiche (freezes well)
$34.00
Flaky crust filled with breakfast sausage, peppers, onions and gooey cheddar cheese baked up with our creamy egg filling. Can’t …
View Details
Southwest Veggie Quiche (freezes well)
$34.00
Flaky crust filled with cheddar, black beans, corn, peppers, onion and tomato-- all baked in our creamy egg filling. You …
View Details
Spinach Bacon Cheddar Quiche (freezes well)
$34.00
Flaky crust filled with fresh spinach, chopped bacon and gooey cheddar cheese baked up with our creamy egg filling. Freezes …
Spirit Sprinkles by Pie Junkie
View Details
12 Baked OSU Sprinkle Cookies
$24.00
One dozen baked Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our Orange + Black sprinkle blend. …
View Details
12 Baked OU Sprinkle Cookies
$24.00
One dozen baked Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our Crimson + Cream sprinkle blend. …
View Details
12 Baked Sprinkle Cookies
$24.00
One dozen baked Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our signature sprinkle blend. A party …
View Details
12 Baked Thunder Sprinkle Cookies
$24.00
One dozen baked Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our Orange + Blue sprinkle blend. …
View Details
12 Take & Bake OSU Sprinkle Cookies
$18.00
One dozen Frozen Take & Bake Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our Orange + …
View Details
12 Take & Bake OU Sprinkle Cookies
$18.00
One dozen Frozen Take & Bake Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our Crimson + …
View Details
12 Take & Bake Sprinkle Cookies
$18.00
One dozen Frozen Take & Bake Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our original sprinkle …
View Details
12 Take & Bake Thunder Sprinkle Cookies
$18.00
One dozen Frozen Take & Bake Spirit Sprinkle sugar cookies featuring scratch-made sugar cookie dough enveloped in our Orange + …
View Details
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake (Large)
$36.00
Our 13" Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake serves 12-16 and features scratch-made cookie dough, baked to perfection and topped with fresh …
View Details
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake (Small)
$18.00
Our 8" Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake serves 4-6 and features scratch-made cookie dough, baked to perfection and topped with fresh …
View Details
Mother's Day Cookie Cake (Small)
$18.00
Our popular 8" chocolate chip cookie cake (serves 4-6) with buttercream frosting and a Happy Mother's Day sign.
View Details
Pre-Sliced Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
$36.00
Our 9x13" rectangular Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake is pre-cut into 16 portions and features scratch-made cookie dough, baked to perfection …
View Details
Pre-Sliced Graduation Cookie Cake
$36.00
Our 9x13" rectangular Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake is pre-cut into 16 portions and features scratch-made cookie dough, baked to perfection …
View Details
Pre-Sliced Thunder Up Cookie Cake
$36.00
Our 9x13" rectangular Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake is pre-cut into 16 portions and features scratch-made cookie dough, baked to perfection …
View Details
Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Cake (Large)
$36.00
Our 13" Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Cake serves 12-16 and features scratch-made cookie dough embedded with sprinkles, baked to perfection and …
View Details
Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Cake (Small)
$18.00
Our 8" Sugar Sprinkle Cookie Cake serves 4-6 and features scratch-made cookie dough, baked to perfection and topped with fresh …
Pie Crusts
Frozen Take & Bake Meals
View Details
Cottage Style Shepherd's Pie (Take & Bake)
$30.00
Frozen Take & Bake hearty beef Shepherd's Pie (Cottage Style) with carrots, celery, onions & peas in a savory sauce …
View Details
Take & Bake Cheddar Sausage Balls (8)
$16.00
Eight frozen take & bake oversized cheddar sausage balls. Bakes straight from the freezer in 20-30 minutes. Great for breakfast …
View Details
Take & Bake Chicken, Mushroom & Thyme Pot Pie (Large)
$34.00
Family Size Take & Bake Chicken, Mushroom & Thyme Pot Pie featuring a savory butter crust with diced chicken breast, …
View Details
Take & Bake Chicken, Mushroom & Thyme Pot Pie (Small)
$12.00
Small Take & Bake Chicken, Mushroom & Thyme Pot Pie featuring a savory butter crust with diced chicken breast, sliced …
View Details
Take & Bake Chicken Pot Pie (Large)
$34.00
Family Size Take & Bake Chicken Pot Pie featuring a savory butter crust with diced chicken breast, celery, onions, carrots …
View Details
Take & Bake Chicken Pot Pie (Small)
$12.00
Small Take & Bake Chicken Pot Pie featuring a savory butter crust with diced chicken breast, celery, onions, carrots & …
View Details
Take & Bake French Toast Crunch Casserole
$22.00
French Toast Casserole with crunchy buttered Cornflakes on top! Bakes straight from frozen. Does not contain nuts but produced in …
View Details
Take & Bake Hashbrown Casserole (Frozen)
$26.00
Just thaw from freezer and bake! Shredded hashbrowns in a creamy sauce with cheddar cheese, diced onions and ham, topped …
View Details
Take & Bake Poppyseed Chicken Casserole (Frozen)
$30.00
Just thaw and bake! Diced chicken breast in a creamy poppyseed sauce, surrounded by buttered Ritz Cracker crumbles. Perfect by …
View Details
Take & Bake TV Dinner (Chicken Pot Pie / Apple Crumble)
$14.50
Frozen TV Dinner featuring Chicken Pot Pie and Apple Crumble dessert all in one! (Take & Bake). Bakes straight from …
View Details
Take & Bake TV Dinner (Chicken Pot Pie / Peach Crumble)
$14.50
Frozen TV Dinner featuring Chicken Pot Pie and Peach Crumble dessert all in one! (Take & Bake). Bakes straight from …
View Details
Take & Bake Veggie Ale Pot Pie (Small)
$12.00
Small Take & Bake Veggie Ale Pot Pie featuring a savory butter crust packed with roasted brussels sprouts, mushrooms, carrots, …
Pie Add-ons
View Details
16 oz. Traditional Whipped Cream (do not freeze)
$6.00
Fresh homemade whipped cream. Made with fresh cream... shelf life of 1-2 days, does not freeze well.
View Details
8 oz. Salted Bourbon Caramel (freezes well)
$10.00
Our famous Salted Bourbon Caramel is now available in an 8 oz. container... pour it over anything! This scratch-made caramel …
View Details
Birthday Candles (24)
$2.00
Pack of 24 Birthday Candles (assorted colors)
View Details
Birthday Topper - Gold
$4.50
Make any pie a birthday pie! Available in Silver or Gold. Place in pie just before serving.
View Details
Birthday Topper - Silver
$4.50
Make any pie a birthday pie! Available in Silver or Gold. Place in pie just before serving.
View Details
Insulated Pie Bag - Lime
$12.00
Our reusable insulated pie bags come in either Teal, Lime Green or Pink and fit 3-4 of our pies, zipped! …
View Details
Insulated Pie Bag - Pink
$12.00
Our reusable insulated pie bags come in either Teal or Pink and fit 3-4 of our pies, zipped! Perfect for …
View Details
Pie Server
$4.00
Our pie server with a stainless steel blade is perfect for serving our pie by the slice. Dishwasher safe!
Merch
View Details
"50 Things to Bake Before You Die" Cookbook
$24.95
Turn your home-baking skills into professional-grade desserts with this mouthwatering baking book featuring recipes from some of the most incredible …
View Details
Birthday Pie Sticker
$4.00
It's my party, and I'll PIE if I want to! Show off your devotion to our popular Birthday Pie with …
View Details
Blue Pie Junkie Mug
$18.00
Let's cut to the chase-- our mugs are microwave and dishwasher safe! This 11 oz. stoneware mug has a glossy …
View Details
Insulated Travel Mug
$28.00
Our Pie Junkie logo is etched into the popular Simple Modern double-walled vacuum insulated travel mug. Holds 12 oz. of …
View Details
Mint Green Pie Junkie Mug
$18.00
Let's cut to the chase-- our mugs are microwave and dishwasher safe! This 11 oz. stoneware mug has a glossy …
We’re not the only ones who love our pies
