Our pie crust is made with real butter, so for that reason none of our pies are dairy free. There is too much flour in our environment to guarantee a gluten free product, so all our pies do contain gluten. Lastly, we make all our sweet pies with real sugar, so none of our products are sugar free (except savory pies like quiche and take & bake pot pies.)

Please refer to the label on the package for instructions specific to that item. If your packaging has been discarded or seems to be missing information, visit our Product Care Page.

At this time, we do not offer delivery and we do not partner with any food delivery services. For large orders or special events, we may be able to arrange delivery through an outside service. Please contact us at orders@piejunkie.com to check availability.

We do! Our frozen "Take and Bake" Pot Pies and Casseroles can remain frozen for up to 3 months before baking and serving. We do not serve them by the slice. We recommend checking our Daily Menu or pre-ordering in advance.

Yes! We have an assortment of sweet slices & quiche that change daily. We do sometimes sell out of flavors throughout the day, so feel free to call or visit our Daily Menu to browse our menu and pre-purchase a slice for same day pick up. You’re also always welcome to call the shop at (405) 605-8767.

Please refer to the label on the package for instructions specific to that item. Your pie is READY TO SERVE without baking unless it is specifically labeled as "Take & Bake." All Quiche are baked but can be reheated with the quiche-specific reheating instructions included on the front of the box. If your packaging has been discarded or seems to be missing information, visit our Product Care Page.

Please refer to the label on the package for instructions specific to that item. If your packaging has been discarded or seems to be missing information, visit our Product Care Page.

Our whole 9” pies serve 6-8 people, depending on how you slice it.

Everything we bake is from scratch and made fresh daily, so to eliminate waste we try not to bake more than we expect to sell. Products with shorter shelf lives and unique specials tend to sell out first, so we encourage you to purchase your favorites earlier in the day so it’s waiting for you when you’re able to pick up. 

Thanksgiving orders usually open early November and will close once we sell out. We usually sell out very quickly once we open Thanksgiving pre-orders, so make sure you check back in October to find out exactly when to place your order. Christmas orders open once we return from Thanksgiving weekend, so give us a call in November for that exact date. We are busier than usual during the holidays, so we operate on a limited menu to increase volume. Alternatively, many of our pies can be frozen for up to 3 months so you can always purchase freezable pies in the fall to secure your holiday items before the rush.

Thanksgiving 2025 pre-orders will be announced in October 2025. 

December/Holiday 2025 pre-orders will be announced in November 2025.

We direct all our charitable giving to non-profit organizations through our Pie it Forward program. Each month we host one Pie it Forward day where we donate a portion of sales to the designated organization for that month.

We collect applicants throughout the year and hold them until January when our staff votes for the upcoming year’s recipients. 

If you would like your registered non-profit organization to be considered, please e-mail your organization’s 501(c)3 designation letter and any supporting information to orders@piejunkie.com.

Due to the high volume of requests received daily, we do not donate individual gift cards.

Preference is given to small, local 501(c)3 nonprofits.

We LOVE making pies for weddings and other special events! We don’t offer staffed catering but we do often make pies for special occasions. Contact emily@piejunkie.com to inquire about availability for your event.

We are glad to provide a custom quote for individually packaged slices for you. Contact emily@piejunkie.com with the date & estimated head count for a menu of available flavors and packages. There is a setup fee associated with bulk slice orders placed in advance.

Our bakers make an assortment of whole pies each day and flavors are bakers’ choice. We can't guarantee that every flavor will be available when you come in, but you can call or visit our Daily Menu to see what’s available and purchase for same-day pickup. If you have your heart set on a specific flavor, we encourage pre-ordering in advance.

You can choose anything we have available for same-day pickup (slices, whole pies, meals, etc.) by visiting our Daily Menu, stopping by or giving us a call. Or, you can place a whole pie pre-order for future pickup (depending on availability.

Yes! Flavors are bakers’ choice and whole pies are first come, first served until sold out. We cannot guarantee any flavor without a pre-order.