FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

How can we help you?

FAQs

You've Got Questions?

Do you serve slices of pie?

Yes! We have an assortment of slices each day including best sellers like Drunken Turtle, Macadamia Key Lime, Peanut Butter Chocolate, Coconut Cream, French Silk and Bird Dog Buttermilk. Fruit pies and quiche change daily, so call ahead if there’s a particular flavor you would like. We do sell out of flavors throughout the day, so feel free to call and hold a slice for same day pick up (holiday weekends are the exception).Please note, we are not able to hold slices or pies via social media.

If I call ahead, can I reserve a pie?

With the exception of holiday weekends, you certainly may! We are glad to hold pies and slices for same day pick up. Our frozen pot pies can also be held for up to 24 hours. Please note, we are not able to hold slices or pies via social media.

How do I order a pie?

Feel free order one online! Click here to visit our online area.

How much is a pie?

Our whole 9” pies serve 6-8 people and range in price from $19 to $22. Slices served in the shop are baked in a larger deep dish pie plate and range from $4.00 - $4.50.

Do you have whole pies for sale?

Yes! They are first come, first served. We set a certain number out each morning and when they are gone, they’re gone! You are welcome to call us at 405.605.8767 to ask what pies we have in our case, and we’ll gladly reserve one for you.  Holiday weekends are the only exception as we do not hold pies on days leading up to a holiday.

Do you have Chicken Pot Pie?

We offer "Take and Bake" chicken pot pies. We make them from scratch and freeze them so you can take them home and bake them when it's convenient. They are first come, first served out of our freezer case. If you’d like to call ahead, we can hold one for 24 hours if we have it in stock.

Where else can I find your pies?

Slices of our pies are sold at Iron Starr, Fassler Hall, All About Cha and Pump Bar.

Do you keep every pie in your case?

No. We have an extensive menu and bake several types each day, but we can't guarantee that every flavor will be available when you come in. If you have a specific pie that would like, your best bet is to place a special order.

Why do you run out of pie?

We are a small bakery. Very small. We bake a certain amount of pie slices and whole pies each day using the freshest seasonal ingredients. When they're gone, that's it for the day. If you need or want something specific, please consider placing an order.

Are any of your pies vegan?

No. Everything we make has butter in it. :)

Do you offer any Gluten Free pies?

So sorry, we don't.

How do I get a donation for our charity?

We do all of our charitable giving and product donations through our Pie it Forward program. Each month we select an organization to support on “Pie it Forward Day” with a percentage of sales and gift certificate donations. If you would like to be considered, please submit any requests via email and include your 501(c)3 designation letter.  Decisions are made in January for that calendar year.

As seen on